For many years in India and around the world, Body Mass Index (BMI) has served as a quick way to gauge whether someone is underweight, normal, overweight, or obese. Indian health policies and national surveys still use BMI thresholds to assess population health risks. However, in 2026, health experts increasingly recognize that BMI doesn’t tell the full story — especially when it comes to muscle mass, metabolic health, and long-term vitality.
This shift isn’t about rejecting BMI outright. It’s about understanding its limitations. Two people with the same BMI can have very different risks for diabetes, heart disease, and frailty — and muscle mass is central to that difference.
Related Tools: BMI Calculator, BMR Calculator, Biomass Index Calculator
Why BMI Alone Is Not Enough
BMI is calculated using height and weight. It does not distinguish between fat and lean tissue, nor does it tell us where fat is stored in the body. This is particularly important in South Asian populations, including Indians, who tend to accumulate visceral fat (fat around the organs) even at lower BMIs — a fact recognized by the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and the National Institute of Nutrition.
Source: https://www.nin.res.in
In contrast, muscle is metabolically active tissue, meaning it uses energy even at rest. People with higher muscle mass often have better glucose regulation, stronger immunity, and lower chronic disease risk. BMI can’t see these differences — which is why two people with a BMI of 24 can have very different health profiles.
Muscle Mass: A Metabolic Powerhouse
Muscle tissue is not just important for strength and mobility. It is a metabolic engine. Skeletal muscle helps clear glucose from the bloodstream after eating, improving insulin sensitivity and reducing the risk of metabolic conditions like type 2 diabetes. This is increasingly important in India, where the number of adults with diabetes is among the highest globally.
Source: https://www.who.int/india
Healthy muscle mass also supports daily physiological resilience — helping the body recover from stress, infection, or injury more effectively. Losing muscle can weaken these systems.
What Is Sarcopenia?
Sarcopenia refers to the age-related loss of muscle mass and strength. It often begins in the 30s and accelerates without regular resistance activity and balanced nutrition. Crucially, sarcopenia can happen even when a person’s weight does not change, meaning BMI remains stable while muscle declines and fat increases. In Indian adults, early onset of sarcopenia is increasingly recognised as a public health concern due to sedentary lifestyles and poor protein intake.
Source: https://main.icmr.nic.in
Declining muscle mass is linked to:
-
Reduced mobility
-
Higher falls and fracture risk
-
Worse metabolic control
-
Lower quality of life
None of these show up in a BMI number alone.
The Shift from “Weight Loss” to “Muscle Preservation”
Traditional health messaging often focuses on reducing weight or lowering BMI. But weight loss can be misleading: without strength training or adequate protein, weight loss frequently includes loss of muscle tissue along with fat. This undermines metabolic health by lowering resting energy expenditure and weakening glucose control.
Instead, modern guidance — supported by nutrition research in India — encourages a focus on losing fat while preserving or building muscle.
Source: https://www.nin.res.in
This approach supports metabolic health, physical function, and long-term resilience better than weight loss alone.
A Fuller Picture: Combining Measurements
To overcome BMI’s limitations, consider additional measurements such as:
-
Waist-to-hip ratio (WHR) — indicator of central fat (visceral fat)
-
Waist circumference — another marker of abdominal fat
-
Muscle strength tests (e.g., grip strength)
These measures help capture metabolic risk that BMI misses.
Example comparison:
| Metric | What It Measures | What It Misses |
|---|---|---|
| BMI | Weight relative to height | Difference between muscle & fat |
| Waist circumference | Abdominal fat | Muscle mass distribution |
| WHR | Fat distribution pattern | Lean tissue / muscle content |
| Muscle strength / mass | Functional muscle health | General weight |
Real-World Example: Same BMI, Different Health
Imagine two adults, both with a BMI of 24:
-
Person A is physically active, performs resistance training, and has a strong muscle base with low visceral fat.
-
Person B is sedentary, with weaker muscles and higher abdominal fat.
Even though both share the same BMI, Person A is likely to have lower cardiometabolic risk, better glucose regulation, and greater physical resilience than Person B.
Practical Steps for Muscle Preservation
Instead of simply watching the scale, focus on strategies that support lean tissue and metabolic health:
-
Resistance Training: Regular strength-building exercise (e.g., weights, resistance bands, bodyweight exercises) stimulates muscle maintenance and growth.
-
Adequate Protein Intake: Ensure daily protein supports muscle repair and synthesis — particularly important for middle-aged and older adults.
-
Balanced Nutrition: Combine protein with micronutrients and complex carbohydrates to fuel activity and recovery.
-
Functional Movement: Daily activity (walking, climbing stairs) supports muscle function even outside gym settings.
These practices are increasingly recommended by Indian health organisations to support healthy aging.
Conclusion: Muscle Matters More Than Just Weight
BMI can be a useful screening tool at a population level, but it has a critical blind spot: it treats all weight the same. The truth is that a body composed of more muscle and less visceral fat functions very differently than one with low muscle and higher fat — even if their BMIs are identical.
In 2026, the focus in health evaluation is no longer just about “being lighter.” It’s about being metabolically stronger. Muscle mass, in this sense, has become the true currency of metabolic health.
Instead of relying on BMI alone, pair it with measurements like waist-to-hip ratio and assessments of strength or muscle mass for a more complete understanding of your health status.
Medical Disclaimer: This tool provides a Body Mass Index (BMI) calculation based on standard formulas. It is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. BMI does not measure body fat directly and can be misleading for athletes, pregnant women, the elderly, or certain ethnic groups. Always consult a healthcare professional before making significant health or lifestyle changes.
Author: Sameer Jahagirdar